[Discuss] "Strip titles" recommendations

[Mark Moss]

On Monday 05 November 2007 22:00, Rob McDonald wrote:
> Why not just have it based on a vote by the nobles? Nobility has to be
> recognised by many people for you to be considered a noble. If only a
> minority supported the king, and he claimed someone to be a commoner, why
> should everyone suddenly treat the accused as such?

I don't think a vote makes much sense.  A vote isn't going to change your 
ancestry:  You're either noble or your not.

IMHO:  If you're going to question a character's nobility, you should at least 
make up some evidence that the character wasn't born a noble.  Maybe throw in 
some examples where the character spoke or acted in an ignoble manner for 
good measure.

Mark Moss