[Discuss] Death Cult of the Snake Goddess (Feature request: heresy)

[Josiah Allen]

On 3/21/07, Gabriel <mail.to.gabriel at gmail.com> wrote:
>
> One of the staples of religious politics in fantasy literature is the
> infiltration of the True Faith by demon-worshiping heretics. I think it'd be
> very interesting to explore the possibility of professing one religion while
> actually espousing a different one.
>
> A heretic priest, while preaching, could spread heresy among the commoners
> while appearing to promote the true faith; the commoners he converts might
> be displayed as faithful to the main religion on most reports, while
> providing power to the heretic cult rather than to their ostensible
> religion.
>
> Heretics might be able work to to defile shrines and temples of other
> faiths, again with no visible changes except that their power and influence
> is invisibly redirected. They might also be able to build hidden shrines of
> their own which are only displayed to heretics or if found through
> deliberate searches.
>
> Priests of the true faiths should be able to spend time (and gold?) in
> efforts to uncover heresy, detect whether a temple has been defiled, etc,
> and there should be an increasing chance for a heresy to be automatically
> revealed anyway as it becomes more popular. A revealed heresy would become
> an ordinary religion in that region, with followership and shrines displayed
> normally. Some mechanism for identifying heretic nobles should be designed
> which addresses the needs of both the loyal clergy and the heretics,
> possibly based on a duel-like inquisition/debate function between the
> heretic and the investigator.
>
> Would there be any interest in such a feature? Would it be entirely
> impractical to code, or unbalancing to existing gameplay? It seems to me
> that this might be one way to let people establish a new foothold for
> religions other than the state-sponsored faith, and address some of the
> concerns raised in LilWolf's "Religion isn't fun" thread.
>
>
>
> --
> Unsubscribing and other list options:
> http://news.battlemaster.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/discuss
>

As described it doesn't seem like a logical view of heresy.  Heretics
weren't priests who taught against their religion, they just taught in such
a way that the church leaders disagreed. (i.e., some christian sects preach
christ was human, and not God, but still worship christ).

I think the more interesting thing would be something where members of a
religion could choose 1 person they thought was a heretic, and if enough of
them did so that person could be banned from the religion.

-- 
"Growth in wisdom may be exactly measured by decrease in bitterness"
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://news.battlemaster.org/pipermail/discuss/attachments/20070321/98a740ae/attachment.htm